This aerial view is the most flattering of viewpoints of the solid Seoul stadium, but its a view that none of its visitors will see, only those that commissioned it from looking at a model.
every postwar olympic stadium
With the possible exception of the 1972 Munich Olympic Stadium, Beijing’s “Birds Nest” stadium, designed by fashionable Swiss architects, Herzog & de Meuron, promises to be the clear winner, architecturally. Here is a list of all 16 post-war Olympic Stadia. Vote for your faves.
| Chart permalink: |
Sadly, the games themselves were marred by the massacre of Israeli athletes, for which the Munich Olympics will be remembered. In design terms, the Munich Olympics was the hands down winner, from the magnificent and original organic shaped stadium tent structure, engineered by Frei Otto (the architect was Behnisch), all the way down to the stylistic graphics by Ottl Aicher.
Although originally built in the 80’s the Athens Stadium was completely renovated for the Olympics, complete with a roof structure by Santiago Calatrava. Although Calatrava has become fashionable as an engineer architect, unlike the Frei Otto’s Munich stadium, where an engineering idea dictates a beautifully original form and interesting space, one can’t help but feel that Calatrava uses structural gymnastics to engineer a shape dictated by taste that is all about structure and forgets about the space within. I find it willful, nowhere more so than the impressive but unoriginal Athens stadium. Many people like it, however.
While many Olympic Stadiums are boring, the Montreal one isn’t, its just bad. A hugely expensive reinforced concrete space ship with a massive, over-engineered, phallus that is designed to hold a delicate retractable roof that never really worked.
The Sydney stadium was the biggest ever built for the Olympics, seating 110,000, but its not a great work of architecture.
Despite the old-fashionedness of the 20’s Baroque Olympic complex which was originally built for an Expo, the Barcelona had a distincly modern flavor, this was nothing to do with the overall architecture, but the smaller individual modern elements dropped in. Rather like Mies van der Rohe’s Barcelona Pavilion, which was an exhibit in the same Baroque complex, when it was built.
The 2008 Olympics will no doubt be the subject of many hand wringing articles Western newspapers as people gaze on Beijings spanking new super modern stadia, railways and airport. Of these, new marvels, the Beijing Olympic stadium, designed by trendy Swiss Architects, Herzog & de Meuron is the most original and interesting. The style may be imitated and may date, but of the stadium as ‘object’ style (as compared with Mexico’s landscaped form or Munich’s organic, pavilion style, this is the best yet. London should look at a re-design of their proposal, because it pales in comparison.
I personally find the Mexico Olympics stadium fascinating and innovative, not so much as a piece of architecture but as a piece of landscaping, it reminds me of Foreign Office Architects Yokohama International Port Terminal, a project which has become seminal yet post dates it by more than 30 years. Somewhere along the lines, stadiums became the domain of buildings and all about fancy roof structures, which is possibly more to do with selling to clients, ideas based upon small models that we look down on, rather than anything more profound.
Apart from the razzamatazz of the closing ceremony, complete with a real jet pack, the LA Olympic stadium, with its surrounding Palm Trees that were cynically designed to be removed afterwards, is a mediocre, neo-classical building worthy of the Nazi Games rather than capitalist ones.
Although it doesn’t look like much from a distance, now, this early picture of it, without the accumulation of dross surrounding it shows that the Helsinki stadium wasn’t bad at all. The asymmetry and modernist tower are part of he modernist Finnish tradition associated with Alvar Aalto and the hanging shard wall could just as well have been designed by Rem Koolhaas, today. The stadium has justifiably been preserved and has undergone a major renovation, recently.
Now demolished and replaced by Norman Foster’s good, but not great, single arch stadium that is not unlike the Athens Olympic Stadium. The original Wembley stadium was called the Empire Stadium, having been built for the British Empire Exhibition in the 20s. The style was imperial with Art Decoish towers, reminiscent of the quintessential piece of British Empire architecture: Lutyen’s Viceroy palace in New Delhi. As with the Tokyo Olympics, the stadium was not the real architectural star, and like the Munich Olympics, the real star was an engineer - Owen Williams, the engineer for the stadium but both engineer and architect on the superlative, Empire Pool, later called Wembley Arena.
This is a simple and solid piece of background architecture. How can you compete in a city that houses the Coliseum.
Despite modern Melbourne’s winning attempts at architecture, Melbourne didn’t have the resources to build a grand new stadium for the Olympics in 1956. Instead, the nondescript Melbourne Cricket Ground was used.
Although the Atlanta Stadium looks like a refit of an existing stadium, rather like Melbourne’s it was actually purpose built and later refit to house the Atlanta Braves. It vies with Melbourne for the title of least inspiring Olympic Stadium.
The Moscow and LA Olympics were sequential, the cold war twins. They represent the infantile ideological posturing that continues to plague the Olympics (for example, the large doors of the Moscow stadium were held open to aid Russian Javelin competitors). Both took place in appropriately neo-fascist, sterile interpretations of classical architecture, about which there is almost nothing to say.
Its unfair to judge Tokyo Olympic architecture, based upon its competent but un-noteworthy stadium, since the architecture was elsewhere, such as Kenzo Tange’s signature Olympic Arena.





